Louisiana abortion law supreme court. Supreme Court to hear Louisiana abortion case in 2020

SCOTUS will review Louisiana abortion law, setting up blockbuster election year showdown

louisiana abortion law supreme court

Writing for the majority, Judge Jerry E. But research shows that serious complications following abortions are. Chief Justice John Roberts, who had dissented in the 2016 Texas case, switched sides to block the lower court ruling from going into effect immediately. It is similar to a Texas law the Supreme Court in 2016, finding it posed an undue burden on a woman's constitutional right to access an abortion. Pittman says if the law stands, it would leave few doctors in Louisiana who perform abortions. He was joined in dissent by Thomas, Alito and Gorsuch.

Next

As Louisiana abortion law goes to Supreme Court, Kennedy introduces more stringent national bill

louisiana abortion law supreme court

Even if that doctor worked seven days a week, the judge said, the physician could not provide for the 10,000 women a year seeking abortions in the state. Wade, the landmark 1973 decision legalizing abortion nationwide, in a 2016 ruling striking down the Texas requirements. Court of Appeals for the 5th Circuit subsequently reversed the district court ruling. Kavanaugh filed a dissent, arguing the law should not be blocked based on a prediction regarding its effects. The Supreme Court on Thursday temporarily blocked a Louisiana abortion regulation that was expected to close all but one or two of the abortion clinics in the state. Josh Blackman, a professor at South Texas College of Law, said only Justice Clarence Thomas openly disagreed with Roe v.

Next

Supreme court likely to rule on Louisiana abortion case months before 2020 election

louisiana abortion law supreme court

That means the court would probably not rule until the first part of next year. The decision came on 5-4 vote. It could be a process of a few months to actually years. The court also said driving distances in the state are much shorter, so the law would not put an undue burden on anyone seeking an abortion. She sponsored the bill as a state representative in 2014. This time, the pair of Trump appointees help create a conservative majority on the for its second go at those types of restrictions imposed by a Louisiana law.

Next

Supreme Court To Hear Louisiana Abortion Case : NPR

louisiana abortion law supreme court

While all proposed abortion restrictions passed through the Louisiana Legislature last year, the federal law faces a steeper battle and is not likely to pass through the Democratic-majority House of Representatives. That would be a tacit acknowledgment that a majority of the justices no longer support the 2016 decision, and an invitation to anti-abortion state legislatures to pass more laws aimed at gutting Roe v. Schumer and House Speaker Nancy Pelosi also filed a brief in the case that was signed on by more than 170 lawmakers. The Louisiana case — June Medical Services v. The bill introduced by Kennedy and Biggs would take that requirement a step further, requiring admitting privileges to a hospital within 15 miles of an abortion clinic. At the time, Chief Justice John Roberts joined with four liberal justices to keep the law on hold before the court could consider whether to review the case on its merits. Kavanaugh were not on the in 2016 when its justices last grappled with hospital admitting privileges and requirements for medical professionals administering abortions in Texas.

Next

Supreme Court To Hear Louisiana Abortion Case : NPR

louisiana abortion law supreme court

The justices acted on an emergency appeal filed by abortion rights advocates who accused the conservative U. The chief justice wanted to give Kavanaugh in particular somewhat of a honeymoon. The Supreme Court will weigh in on a Louisiana abortion law that put restrictions on clinics that provide abortions. The Supreme Court struck down a nearly identical Texas law in 2016 in Whole Woman's Health v. Court of Appeals for the 5th Circuit, and a three-judge panel voted 2 to 1 to allow the state law to go into effect. Two weeks ago, lawyers for the Center for Reproductive Rights filed an emergency appeal asking the high court to again put the law on hold.

Next

Supreme Court To Hear Louisiana Abortion Case : NPR

louisiana abortion law supreme court

Emboldened by the Supreme Court's new conservative majority, a number of conservative-led states this year approved virtual bans on abortion, hoping to eventually trigger a Supreme Court review that could significantly narrow or abolish the right to terminate a pregnancy. The , in a 5-4 decision, halted the law from taking effect this year. The ruling prompted unusually strong dissents from others on the 5th Circuit. In a region with many restrictive abortion laws and a declining number of clinics, Newton says the women she counsels to get here. They said hospitals did not want to extend privileges to doctors who rarely sent patients for emergency care. He said the closing of clinics would not impose driving distances as long as those in Texas, and he said that it was easier to get hospital admitting privileges in Louisiana.

Next

The Louisiana Clinic At The Center Of Abortion Case Before Supreme Court . News

louisiana abortion law supreme court

He concluded that because one or two clinics would remain in operation, the overall effect on women seeking an abortion would not be substantial. Finally, Smith rejected the district court's factual finding that the law would make access to abortion more difficult for 70% of women seeking abortions in the state. The decision in the Texas case was handed down a few months after Justice Antonin Scalia died. Supreme Court on March 4, with a decision expected just months before the 2020 election. The difference between then and now is that Justice Anthony Kennedy, who cast the decisive fifth vote in the 2016 Texas case, retired last June and has now been replaced by Trump appointee Kavanaugh.

Next

Supreme Court blocks restrictive Louisiana abortion law by 5

louisiana abortion law supreme court

The Justices also voted to take a related petition challenging the standing of Louisiana's abortion clinics to bring the legal challenge on behalf of their patients. Wade decision in 1973, she notes. Eleven judges on the appeals court are Republican appointees, five of them Trump appointees. The question, Kavanaugh wrote, is whether three clinic doctors without hospital admitting privileges can obtain them. Justices Clarence Thomas, Samuel Alito, Neil Gorsuch and Brett Kavanaugh opposed the stay. Abortion providers have challenged the legislation, saying it resembles a Texas law that the struck down in a 5-3 ruling three years ago. A stringent Louisiana abortion clinic admitting privileges law — which is currently not in effect — is already set to make its way to the Supreme Court in March.

Next