The national popular vote interstate compact. How to Defeat the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact

National Popular Vote Interstate Compact: Supporters Woo Skeptical Conservatives

the national popular vote interstate compact

For example, Democrats and Republicans have split the national popular vote in the past eight presidential elections back to 1980, past 12 presidential elections back to 1964, past 16 elections back to 1948, past 22 elections back to 1920 and past 26 elections back to 1904. I could foresee class action suits against States that support such a preposterous position. It is obvious why liberals, whose political philosophy and preferences are anathema to much of the nation, would want to do this. Law professors and brothers and defended the constitutionality of such a plan. What if a participating state tries to leave the Compact during or after an election? At the same time, it is clear that, as of 2009, there is no consensus on the form of a constitutional amendment to establish a direct election and there is no energy on Capitol Hill to advance an amendment. These state laws would only be once the compact included enough states to control a majority of the electoral college 270 votes , thus guaranteeing that the national popular vote winner would also win the electoral college.

Next

A National Popular Vote for President

the national popular vote interstate compact

States enter the compact by passing enabling legislation through their state legislatures. In 1948 and 1968, Strom Thurmond and George Wallace won significant numbers of southern states and their electoral votes; small popular vote shifts in a few states would have put them in a position to bargain after the election. The Electoral College process is in the Constitution so getting rid of it entirely would require a constitutional amendment. Politifact has a good rundown of the potential legal challenges. Even more importantly, the very fact that the presidential election would again be decided by the U. The piece does a fine job of describing the machinery of working around the ectoral college.

Next

What Is the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact?

the national popular vote interstate compact

Support and Opposition Support is the primary group advocating for the interstate compact. They would know that the candidate with the most votes wins. As to money, candidates already are trying to raise as much money as they can. When conservatives lose a presidential election, they take a moment to lick their wounds, then use the rest of their time in the wilderness to examine, analyze, and strategize to win the next election. Demonization and the End of Civil Debate in American Politics , Professor of Political Science, Western Washington University Author, Reforming the Republic: Democratic Institutions for the New America , Senior Fellow in the Penn Program on Democracy, Citizenship, and Constitutionalism, University of Pennsylvania Author of more than 200 scholarly articles and more than forty books, Paul Finkelman is a specialist in American legal history, race relations, slavery, and civil liberties. A primary reason for National Popular Vote Inc.

Next

National Popular Vote Interstate Compact: 5 Fast Facts

the national popular vote interstate compact

Our presidential election system is the byproduct of historical forces and political compromises made in 1787 that no longer have contemporary relevance or political resonance—gratefully, the nation no longer needs to balance the political strength of pro-slavery and anti-slavery states. Thank you for your elucidation of the Constitutional issue raised by the compact. Furthermore, states historically have acted on their power to expand democracy in presidential elections without waiting for a constitutional amendment: it was states that took action to ensure popular elections within states for elector allocation, and that first expanded suffrage rights to include women, African Americans, Native Americans and citizens who did not own property. Here is the precise language Article I, Section 4, emphasis added : The Times, Places and Manner of holding Elections for Senators and Representatives, shall be prescribed in each State by the Legislature thereof; but the Congress may at any time by Law make or alter such Regulations, except as to the Places of chusing Senators. The nationwide Electoral Vote distribution typically changes with every census. There were times during the campaign when the polls were close enough to trigger traumatic memories of the 2000 election — recounts, legal battles, uncertainty.

Next

A National Popular Vote for President

the national popular vote interstate compact

Until that happens, states continue to apportion their electoral votes according to their current rules. American politics is in a period of narrow division between the major parties. Tennessee , this Compact does not require congressional approval — the states are entirely allowed to do it themselves. A National Popular Vote for President All voters should be valued equally in presidential elections, no matter where they live. It seems to me that The National Popular Vote Interstate Compact is nothing more then of letting California and New York to pick all our Presidents in the future because Democrats want it that way, hate making it Political but we all know that it is , Isn't that what the Founding Fathers were trying to protect us against? Who would benefit from the Compact? Will the Compact disadvantage small states? Of the 18 states with the smallest populations, 10 experienced absolutely no television ads or candidate visits with public events during the peak season of 2008 campaigns.

Next

How to Defeat the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact

the national popular vote interstate compact

The capped the size of the House at 435, and the increased the number of electors by 3 to the current 538 in 1961. It was passed by at least one legislative chamber in , , , , , , , and. Web-based versions of these endorsements can be found via the links provided. The compact is designed to push presidential candidates to run national campaigns that seek votes in most states. In the first case, Obama would have needed to carry 50. .

Next

What Is the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact?

the national popular vote interstate compact

The Compact is simply the agreement of a state to appoint electors who would vote for the national popular vote winner. Why change the current Electoral College system at all? Note: The agreement would be in effect only among the assenting political entities. It took days of votes in the House before Jefferson won. This knowledge of the probable outcome decreases their incentive to vote. National Conference of State Legislatures. If a State votes for a candidate for President, what right does that State legislature have to vote the other party in the Electoral College? The Best Solution to the Electoral College The Electoral College, the mechanism by which Americans indirectly select their presidents, is a profound violation of the democratic principle of one person, one vote. The bill will go into effect when enacted by states with an additional 74 electoral votes.

Next

The National Popular Vote, Explained

the national popular vote interstate compact

In 1800, backers of Thomas Jefferson wanted to avoid such a result. This is a state power, and it does not challenge the supremacy of the federal government. And finally, the Electoral College works in such a way that only a small handful of states become battleground, or swing, states. FairVote supports the National Popular Vote plan to ensure that every vote for president is equally valued no matter where it is cast. Does the National Popular Vote plan eliminate the Electoral College? In this short post, I do not want to reprise. Eleven of the 12 smallest states did not have a single campaign visit. Gore's 540,000-vote margin amounted to 3.

Next